Free cookie consent management tool by TermsFeed
November 14, 2016
|
Career Advice

How to Handle a Tough Interviewer

November 14, 2016
|
Career Advice
Download Resource;

Few situations are more uncomfortable than walking into an interview expecting a friendly conversation and finding yourself facing an interviewer who seems determined to challenge everything you say.

Perhaps they're abrupt. Perhaps they're questioning every answer. Maybe they're highlighting weaknesses in your CV, interrupting your responses, or showing very little warmth or encouragement.

It can feel intimidating.

However, before assuming the interview is going badly, it's important to remember that not all tough interviewers are difficult people. In many cases, they are deliberately testing how you perform under pressure, particularly for roles where resilience, stakeholder management, problem-solving, and composure are critical.

This is especially true in Facilities Management, where professionals regularly deal with operational disruptions, demanding stakeholders, contractor disputes, compliance issues, emergency situations, and competing priorities.

The good news? A challenging interview can often present the perfect opportunity to demonstrate the very qualities employers are looking for.

Understand Why They're Being Challenging

Before reacting emotionally, consider what may be driving the interviewer's approach.

They may be:

  • Testing your resilience under pressure.
  • Assessing how you handle confrontation.
  • Evaluating your communication skills.
  • Looking for inconsistencies in your CV.
  • Measuring your emotional intelligence.
  • Simulating the types of conversations you may face in the role.

For example, if you're interviewing for a Facilities Manager position, you may regularly have to deal with frustrated occupants, demanding senior stakeholders, underperforming contractors, or urgent compliance issues.

An interviewer may deliberately create pressure to see howyou respond.

Understanding this helps you remain objective rather thantaking their behaviour personally.

Stay Calm and Professional

The quickest way to lose control of a tough interview is tobecome defensive.

If an interviewer challenges your experience, questions your decisions, or appears sceptical of your achievements, avoid the temptation to argue.

Instead:

  • Remain calm.
  • Listen carefully.
  • Pause before responding.
  • Keep your tone measured and professional.
  • Focus on facts and evidence.

Strong candidates demonstrate confidence without becoming confrontational.

Remember that professionalism under pressure is often exactly what the interviewer is assessing.

Know Your CV Inside Out

Tough interviewers frequently target areas they believe candidates may struggle to explain.

Common examples include:

  • Employment gaps.
  • Short-term positions.
  • Career changes.
  • Lack of qualifications.
  • Missed promotions.
  • Project failures.
  • Salary progression.

If you know these questions are likely to arise, prepareyour answers in advance.

For example:

Question:

"I can see you left your previous role after only 18months. Why was that?"

Weak Response:

"I didn't really enjoy it."

Strong Response:

"The role gave me valuable experience managing a multi-site FM portfolio, but after successfully delivering several major projects, I was looking for a broader strategic challenge. The opportunity wasn't available internally, which is why I began exploring new opportunities."

Preparation allows you to answer confidently rather thanbecoming flustered.

Use Evidence, Not Opinions

One of the best ways to handle challenging questions is tosupport your answers with evidence.

Instead of saying:

"I'm good at contractor management."

Say:

"I inherited a contractor delivering below SLA standards. By introducing monthly performance reviews and clearer KPIs, we improved compliance scores from 82% to 98% within six months."

Specific examples are difficult to challenge and instantlyadd credibility.

Whenever possible, use measurable achievements:

  • Cost savings.
  • Compliance improvements.
  • Project outcomes.
  • Team performance.
  • Sustainability achievements.
  • Customer satisfaction improvements.
Don't Be Afraid to Pause

Many candidates feel pressured to answer immediately.

You don't have to

When faced with a difficult question:

  • Take a breath
  • Gather your thoughts.
  • Structure your response

A short pause demonstrates thoughtfulness and confidence.

Rushed answers often create more problems than they solve.

Turn Pressure Into Opportunity

A difficult question can often be an opportunity to showcase strengths that might not otherwise emerge.

For example:

Question:

"Tell me about a project that didn't go according toplan."

This isn't necessarily an attempt to expose weakness.

It's an opportunity to demonstrate:

  • Accountability
  • Problem-solving
  • Leadership
  • Resilience
  • Learning agility

Strong candidates don't pretend they've never made mistakes.

They explain what happened, what they learned, and how they improved as a result.

Build Rapport Where Possible

Not every interviewer responds to rapport-building, but manydo.

Simple techniques can help create a more constructive conversation:

  • Maintain eye contact
  • Smile naturally
  • Show genuine interest
  • Ask thoughtful questions
  • Acknowledge their perspective.

Particularly in Facilities Management, where stakeholder relationships are central to success, demonstrating strong interpersonal skills can be just as important as demonstrating technical knowledge.

Remember: You're Interviewing Them Too

Candidates often forget that interviews work both ways.

While you are being assessed, you're also evaluating:

  • The organisation
  • The leadership team
  • The culture
  • The working environment
  • Future opportunities

If an interviewer is unnecessarily rude, dismissive, disrespectful, or aggressive throughout the process, it may reveal something important about the organisation itself.

Ask yourself:

  • Would I want to work for this person?
  • Is this reflective of the company culture?
  • Would I feel supported here?

The interview process should leave both parties excitedabout the possibility of working together.

Facilities Management Interviews Can Be Tough by Design

For Facilities Management professionals, challenging interviews are increasingly common.

Employers may deliberately test candidates on:

  • Health and safety incidents.
  • Contractor failures
  • Budget reductions
  • Emergency situations
  • Difficult stakeholder relationships.
  • Compliance breaches
  • Business continuity scenarios

Examples include:

"What would you do if the building lost power during business hours?"

"How would you respond to a serious health and safety breach discovered during an audit?"

"A senior stakeholder wants a project completed by an unrealistic deadline. How would you manage the situation?"

These questions are not designed to catch candidates out.

They are designed to assess judgement, decision-making, and leadership under pressure.

Key Takeaways

A tough interviewer doesn't automatically mean a bad interview.

In many cases, they are assessing how you perform when challenged.

To succeed:

  • Stay calm and professional.
  • Prepare thoroughly.
  • Know your CV inside out.
  • Use evidence-based examples.
  • Don't become defensive.
  • Treat difficult questions as opportunities.
  • Remember that interviews are a two-way process.

The ability to remain composed under pressure is one of the most valuable skills any Facilities Management professional can demonstrate. If you can do that during a difficult interview, you've already shown many of the qualities employers are looking for.